Despite steering the Detroit Lions through one of the most impressive transformations in recent NFL memory, Dan Campbell is still taking heat from critics. A recent report by Alicia Grimes of Action Network placed Campbell as the sixth most overrated head coach in the league, based on analysis of fan sentiment across social media. Not exactly a flattering spot, especially for a coach credited with redefining the culture in Detroit.
Who’s Ranked Higher on the Overrated List?
Campbell’s position on the list is certainly eye-catching, but he’s in notable company. Leading the rankings is longtime Steelers coach Mike Tomlin, followed by Seattle’s Mike Macdonald, Denver’s Sean Payton, San Francisco’s Kyle Shanahan, and Jim Harbaugh of the Chargers. The group features both accomplished veterans and newer names, which makes Campbell’s inclusion all the more surprising for those who follow the Lions closely.
How Did He End Up Here?
Let’s not ignore the facts: when Campbell took the reins in 2021, the Lions were at rock bottom. The team managed only three wins that year. But under his leadership, Detroit has posted winning records for three straight seasons — 9-8 in 2022, a solid 12-5 in 2023, and an outstanding 15-2 campaign in 2024. That kind of success doesn’t just happen — it’s a result of strong leadership and a shift in team mentality.
However, with success comes elevated expectations. After being seen as serious contenders for the Super Bowl, the Lions’ season came to a disappointing end with a loss to the Commanders. It didn’t help that injuries ravaged the defense, leaving Campbell and his staff scrambling with limited options.
Is the Backlash Justified?
In reality, probably not. While the loss was disappointing, it’s tough to blame Campbell when his defense was depleted by injuries. Any coach would struggle to win playoff games when key players are sidelined. Still, the blame game often points straight to the head coach when a team falls short.
What’s Next for Campbell and the Lions?
The bright side is that Campbell seems unfazed by the chatter. With general manager Brad Holmes continuing to build a strong roster, and assuming better health across the team, Detroit is primed to make another run in 2025. If Campbell can finally push them into a deep playoff run — or even the Super Bowl — the only list he’ll care about is the postseason bracket.