The Columbus Blue Jackets are entering the 2025 offseason with a sense of urgency and opportunity. After missing the playoffs yet again, it’s no secret that this franchise needs not just incremental upgrades—but foundational pieces who bring leadership, grit, and a winning pedigree. That brings us to one of the most intriguing potential free agent targets available this summer: Jonathan Toews.
Yes, that Jonathan Toews. While the legendary former Chicago Blackhawks captain has battled through health setbacks in recent years, his return to NHL action has sparked a surge of interest among teams looking for a seasoned leader to help guide a young locker room. Columbus, with a roster stacked with youthful talent but lacking veteran identity, could be the perfect landing spot.
The idea of Toews in a Blue Jackets sweater may have seemed impossible just a few years ago, but times have changed. Toews proved in limited action this past season that he can still contribute meaningfully, especially in a depth role. He may not be the 70-point dynamo he once was, but his faceoff acumen, penalty killing prowess, and locker room presence remain elite. Pair that with the Blue Jackets’ desperate need for structure and accountability, and the fit starts to look incredibly promising.
What’s especially enticing for Columbus fans is the intangible value Toews would bring. With Boone Jenner already carrying a heavy leadership load, adding someone like Toews could help elevate expectations and instill a championship mentality within the room. Younger players like Adam Fantilli, Kent Johnson, and David Jiricek could benefit immensely from simply sharing ice time and practices with a future Hall of Famer.
Let’s also not overlook the potential marketing boost. Toews is still a recognizable name across the hockey world. His signing would not only turn heads but might also reignite interest among casual fans who’ve drifted from the team during its recent struggles. Toews’ impact extends beyond the box score—he brings credibility, experience, and a serious tone to a franchise that has often been seen as an NHL afterthought.
From a financial perspective, Toews would likely command a short-term, incentive-laden deal—something that wouldn’t cripple the Blue Jackets’ cap flexibility. That’s an ideal scenario for a club that wants to add meaningful pieces without compromising the longer-term build. And if Toews flourishes in Columbus? Even better. He could become a trade chip at the deadline or mentor the team into genuine playoff contention.
Of course, this isn’t without risk. Health concerns remain real. But if there’s one thing the Blue Jackets have shown in recent years, it’s a willingness to take swings. This would be a calculated one—and potentially the most impactful move of their offseason.
Don’t be surprised if we see Toews touring Nationwide Arena this July. The Blue Jackets need a culture change, a spark, and a seasoned voice in their locker room. Jonathan Toews could check every one of those boxes.
Stay tuned, Columbus. This could get very interesting.