Zach Werenski’s phenomenal 2024-25 season was just capped with a silver lining that feels more like a snub than an honor. The Columbus Blue Jackets defenseman finished second in Norris Trophy voting, and while it’s certainly an accomplishment to be recognized among the NHL’s elite, there’s a growing belief — and plenty of evidence — that Werenski should be holding the trophy, not just admiring it from a distance.
The Norris Trophy, awarded annually to the NHL’s top defenseman, was expected by many to go to Werenski after a dominant season both offensively and defensively. Werenski finished the year with a career-high in points, quarterbacked one of the league’s most improved power plays, and logged heavy minutes in all situations. He was the anchor on a Blue Jackets blue line that took enormous strides from the previous season, and his impact on and off the puck was unmatched. Night after night, Werenski shut down top lines, transitioned the puck with elite efficiency, and provided leadership in a room that needed it more than ever.
But the voters saw it differently, handing the Norris to a familiar name from a bigger market. And while that player certainly had a strong season, the decision left many scratching their heads. Analysts, former players, and fans alike have taken to social media to voice their disbelief, pointing to advanced metrics and game film that clearly favor Werenski’s all-around game. The disappointment is palpable, especially in Columbus, where the team and its supporters know just how much their star defenseman carried the load this year.
This was not just a good season for Werenski — it was special. His consistency, poise under pressure, and ability to dominate all zones were elite. He was more than just a statistical marvel; he was the heartbeat of the team. His leadership helped bring the Blue Jackets back into playoff contention, and his clutch performances often turned the tide in tight games. If ever there was a season to recognize a defenseman whose value transcends the box score, this was it.
The Norris voting process has long drawn criticism for favoring offensive production or name recognition over complete defensive dominance. This year’s result only fuels that narrative. Werenski, despite being everything a Norris winner should be, walks away with second place and the admiration of those who actually watched him game in and game out.
The good news? Werenski isn’t going anywhere. He’s in the prime of his career, motivated more than ever, and already looking ahead. If this season was his breakout moment on the national stage, the next one might be his coronation. Columbus has a superstar on the back end, and the league is on notice. The Norris may have slipped away this year, but make no mistake: Zach Werenski is just getting started.