It’s the kind of debate that fires up late-night hockey discussions, splits fanbases down the middle, and lingers long after both legends have hung up their pads. Henrik Lundqvist and Carey Price—two of the greatest goaltenders of the modern era. Both were icons for their franchises, backbones of their national teams, and universally respected across the league. But when it comes down to one question—who would you rather have in their prime—it’s anything but a clear-cut answer.
Henrik Lundqvist, the “King of New York,” built his legacy in the spotlight of Madison Square Garden, carrying the Rangers to relevance and keeping them competitive for over a decade. His technical excellence, calm demeanor, and elite lateral movement made him one of the most consistent goalies of his time. With a career save percentage of .918 and over 450 wins, Lundqvist was a model of durability and excellence. He won the Vezina Trophy in 2012 and dragged the Rangers to the 2014 Stanley Cup Final almost singlehandedly.
Across the Eastern Conference, Carey Price was crafting a career that was equal parts brilliance and mystique. Playing under the unforgiving lights of Montreal, Price was often the Canadiens’ last line of defense—and sometimes their only line. When he was at his best, no one looked better. The 2014-15 season remains one of the greatest single seasons by a goaltender in modern NHL history: Vezina Trophy, Hart Trophy, Ted Lindsay Award, and Jennings Trophy, all in one year. Price was untouchable, playing with a calm and poise that mesmerized fans and frustrated shooters alike.
Statistically, Lundqvist had the edge in career wins and playoff appearances, but Price had the peak that few goaltenders ever reach. While Lundqvist’s playoff consistency was remarkable—dragging average Rangers squads to the postseason year after year—Price’s playoff run in 2021 showed the kind of magic he could summon, carrying a flawed Canadiens team to the Stanley Cup Final.
In terms of style, the contrast is striking. Lundqvist played deep in his crease, relying on positioning and rapid reflexes. Price, meanwhile, was a technician—a goaltender who moved as little as possible and let the puck come to him. Watching him play was like witnessing a masterclass in goaltending fundamentals, and when he was on, he made the most difficult saves look effortless.
So who would you rather have in their prime?
If you’re building a team for a consistent playoff run, Henrik Lundqvist might be your man. He gave the Rangers a chance to win every single night, no matter who was in front of him. But if you’re looking for the highest peak, the goaltender who could carry a team on his back to improbable heights, Carey Price might be your pick. His ability to steal games—and series—was legendary when he was at full health and confidence.
In truth, there’s no wrong answer. Both goaltenders were generational talents who defined an era of hockey. The debate will rage on in forums, bars, and comment sections for years to come. But that’s part of what makes the sport great—two legends, two unforgettable careers, and one question that will never have a unanimous answer. Who would you choose