In one of the wildest behind-the-scenes stories to surface this offseason, multiple league sources have confirmed shocking details about a failed three-team blockbuster trade that would have shaken the very core of the NHL. The deal in question reportedly involved Toronto Maple Leafs winger Mitch Marner, Colorado Avalanche superstar Mikko Rantanen, and — you guessed it — the Vegas Golden Knights acting as the critical third party in a deal that came painfully close to completion.
The framework of the deal was ambitious and complex, as one might expect with names of this magnitude being tossed around. According to league insiders, the initial discussions were spearheaded by Vegas, who saw a unique opportunity to act as a facilitator while acquiring high-end talent themselves. The Maple Leafs were prepared to part ways with Marner, Colorado was exploring creative cap solutions involving Rantanen, and Vegas was ready to swing big — again.
Here’s how the trade was reportedly structured: Mitch Marner would have been sent to Vegas, Mikko Rantanen would have made a shocking move to Toronto, and Colorado would receive a package of top-tier draft picks, prospects, and roster-ready players from both teams. All three organizations were believed to be operating under intense pressure — Toronto’s playoff failures, Colorado’s looming cap crunch, and Vegas’ never-ending pursuit of elite firepower were all key motivations behind the proposed deal.
At the heart of the collapse were two critical stumbling blocks. First, contract negotiations surrounding a potential Rantanen extension proved to be too complicated for Toronto’s front office to navigate in the short time they had before Marner’s no-movement clause became active. Rantanen, heading into the final year of his deal, was reportedly seeking a number that would eclipse Auston Matthews’ $13.25 million AAV — a number Toronto was not comfortable committing to without shedding more salary elsewhere.
Second, Vegas reportedly insisted on receiving a high-impact player in addition to Marner — possibly Samuel Girard or Bowen Byram — to balance the trade and compensate for the depth they would be moving. Colorado was unwilling to part with both assets in one move, and the negotiations stalled. As the hours ticked down, the framework unraveled, and each team pulled back, unwilling to compromise further.
Multiple sources confirmed that players involved were unaware of the trade’s existence until after talks had already fallen apart. The level of secrecy maintained throughout the process was extraordinary. Only a handful of executives and agents were looped in, as the deal required a synchronized agreement from all sides before it could be announced. The news of its failure, however, has now opened the floodgates.
For fans in Toronto, this revelation adds an entirely new dimension to the Marner conversation. It’s not just that he could be traded — it’s that the Leafs were willing to ship him out in exchange for another franchise cornerstone in Rantanen. That alone signals a seismic shift in how the Leafs view their core, and perhaps even hints at more blockbuster ideas still on the table.
Colorado, for their part, will need to address Rantanen’s future quickly. The fact they were even willing to entertain moving him speaks volumes about their long-term planning, especially with key contracts looming and their championship window still wide open.
And as for Vegas? Well, once again, they were right in the middle of the chaos, pulling strings, making bold moves, and looking to add yet another marquee name to their already stacked roster. Don’t be surprised if they’re back at the table soon — whether it’s Marner, another star, or a different multi-team blockbuster altogether.
What’s clear now is that this failed trade wasn’t just smoke — it was fire, and the embers are still burning.
—